What happened
It was supposed to be the highlight of the season, the annual Christmas Party at the Evergreen Lodge in Aspen.
Guests gathered under twinkling lights for the traditional wine tasting, where heiress Charlotte Whitmore unveiled a legendary bottle: the Noël Cuvée 1985.
But when the first glasses were poured, something felt off.
The flavor didn’t match the legend. The aroma was wrong.
And yet, the bottle looked perfect.
Somewhere between the cellar and the celebration, the true Noël Cuvée had been switched.
What stood beneath the Christmas tree was no gift at all, but a carefully wrapped deception.
Now, among half-drunk glasses, torn wrapping paper, and whispered secrets, the guests must uncover who replaced the wine… and why this Christmas gift was never meant to be opened.
the suspects
Four suspects, one legendary bottle — and too many secrets.
Each has a motive. Only one crossed the line.
Charlotte Whitmore
Owner of the Evergreen Lodge and host of the Christmas Party
Étienne Duval
French sommelier presenting the wines.
Sophia Delgado
Celebrity ski instructor
Victor Hargrove
Businessman
Includes 4 optional guest roles to expand the mystery up to 8 players.
what needs to be revealed?
game overview
-
Players: 4 main roles + 4 optional guests
-
Duration: ±90 minutes
-
Host required: Yes (can also play as a character)
-
Setting: A Christmas wine tasting at the Evergreen Lodge in Aspen takes an unsettling turn when the legendary Noël Cuvée 1985, unveiled as the evening’s grand gift, tastes nothing like it should.
-
Includes: Character files, evidence, host guide
-
Reveal: Via secret code on a dedicated web page
-
Print & play: Instant digital download (PDF)
explore more cases
The Case of the Christmas Gift is just the beginning.
Soon, new mysteries will take you to unexpected places.
Coming soon:
-
The Case of the Unscripted Toast - At a glamorous Bollywood premiere, an unscripted toast with a forbidden whisky steals the spotlight — but who orchestrated the scene, and why?
-
The Case of the Andean Omen - A pisco tasting in a remote Peruvian hacienda takes a dark turn when a forbidden toast awakens something that was never meant to rise.
Stay curious. Stay suspicious.
ready to play?
Download The Case of the Christmas Gift and host your own unforgettable mystery night.
Just gather your guests, pick a few bottles of wine, and print the game files.
Buy now and bring the mystery to your tasting table.
A Printable Christmas Mystery Game – Wine, Whispers & Holiday Intrigue
The Case of the Christmas Gift is a printable Christmas wine tasting mystery game for adults who love elegant storytelling, cozy winter nights, and a festive twist of deception. It’s designed as a warm, atmospheric alternative to murder mysteries — perfect for holiday gatherings where you want intrigue, not intensity.
This game answers a clear search intent:
“Is there a printable Christmas mystery game for adults that pairs with wine but involves no murder?”
Yes. This is exactly that.
What makes this Christmas mystery game unique
-
No murders, no dark themes — the mystery centers on a rare bottle revealed at the lodge’s Christmas gala.
-
No acting or costumes required — just guided prompts, conversation, and discovery.
-
Designed to pair beautifully with real wine tastings, making it ideal for winter celebrations.
-
Rich, cinematic lodge atmosphere that turns any evening into a holiday experience.
Who this game is perfect for
Ideal for adults who want a festive, story-driven wine night:
-
holiday dinners and Christmas parties
-
winter wine tastings with friends
-
small groups (4–8 players, host included)
-
fans of snowy lodge settings and refined intrigue
-
anyone seeking a smart alternative to murder mystery games
What the experience looks like
You and your group step into the Evergreen Lodge in Aspen, where the legendary Noël Cuvée 1985 is unveiled during the annual Christmas gala.
But when the first sip reveals something unexpected, the evening shifts from celebration to quiet investigation — beneath twinkling lights, drifting snow, and the glow of the Christmas tree.
During the game, you will:
-
take on a printed character role,
-
share tasting notes and secrets,
-
reveal clues through guided prompts,
-
and work together to discover why the Noël Cuvée isn’t what it seems.
The mystery unfolds through conversation, hints, and holiday atmosphere — not violence or heavy drama.
Why choose this printable holiday mystery
If you want a cozy, elegant alternative to murder mysteries — something designed for Christmas wine tasting nights, festive gatherings, and winter evenings with friends — The Case of the Christmas Gift delivers an unforgettable experience with minimal prep.
A printable game.
A shared wine tasting.
A Christmas mystery wrapped in candlelight and snow.
You can order this printable directly from my shop, or through Etsy if that’s where you love to shop. Either way, it’s the same design made to make your tasting night unforgettable.
Disclaimer
This game is a fictional mystery experience designed for entertainment purposes only. All characters, events, and distillery references are entirely fictional or used fictitiously. Any resemblance to real persons, living or dead, or actual brands is purely coincidental. Please enjoy responsibly — and remember, the only real mystery is how well you know your dram.
This game is an original creation by The Foodie Finds and may not be copied, reproduced, or resold in any form.
This mystery game is entirely fictional and intended for entertainment purposes only. While it may reference historical themes or settings, no real-world connections are implied. We aim to tell an engaging story with respect for all people and cultures.